Who Owns the Warren Occult Artifacts Today? Judy Spera, Tony Spera, and the $1 Million Estate Sale

Read about in-depth analysis concerning Who Owns the Warren Occult Artifacts Today? Judy Spera, Tony Spera, and the $1 Million Estate Sale.

The white ranch-style house on Knollwood Street became an unbearable administrative liability after Lorraine Warren died in April 2019 at the age of 92. For years, the town of Monroe cited the estate for zoning violations. Commercial tour buses clogged narrow residential avenues. Paranormal tourists frequently trespassed across the manicured lawns at 3:00 a.m. hoping to catch a glimpse of the walkout basement where the collection sat.

When reporting confirmed in August 2025 that Elton Castee had moved to buy the historic Warren residence, viral rumors suggested a fire sale of occult curiosities had taken place. That was not the case. The sale concerned the physical real estate and select non-occult residential furnishings. The Monroe Sun documented that Castee's path to acquiring the property originated through historical preservation interests, rather than a plan to convert the residential parcel into an unauthorized roadside tourist trap.

The transaction effectively decoupled the Warren real estate from the physical repository of their investigations. By relinquishing the residential home, Judy and Tony Spera settled long-standing friction with local municipal authorities while privatizing the physical upkeep of the grounds.