Ultimate Homemade Chicken and Dumplings Guide: from Scratch Dough to Rich Broth
When dumplings turn out rubbery, excessive mechanical action is almost always to blame. Kneading drop dumpling dough activates the glutenin and gliadin proteins in wheat flour, forming an elastic mesh that traps steam too rigidly. For rolled dumplings, rest the dough on the counter for 15 to 20 minutes before rolling it out. Resting relaxes the gluten network, allowing you to roll the sheet down to a 1/8-inch thickness without spring-back or tough results.
If your rolled dumplings turn into pasty paste that clogs the pot, shake off excess bench flour before dropping the strips into the broth. A light dusting thickens the sauce nicely; a heavy blanket of raw starch turns broth into glue. If you find your drop dumplings undercooked in the center after the timer rings, resist the urge to turn up the flame. Keep the pot covered, remove it from the burner entirely, and let residual heat finish steaming the centers for an extra 5 minutes.