Tavern on the Green Timeline: the Complete History from 1934 Sheepfold to 2026 Cultural Destination
Before diners sipped dry martinis under walnut beams, the building housed two hundred Dorset sheep. Designed by architect Jacob Wrey Mould in 1870, the Gothic-revival brick-and-granite complex served a strictly pastoral purpose: sheltering the flock that grazed Sheep Meadow and housing the shepherd who tended them. The sheep added rural charm to Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux’s landscape design, keeping the lawns trimmed while reinforcing an idyllic escape from rapid industrialization.
That pastoral fiction ended in 1934. Master builder Robert Moses assumed command of the unified New York City Department of Parks with an aggressive urban mandate. Moses saw the flock as an anachronism and a sanitary nuisance during the lean years of the Great Depression. He banished the sheep to Prospect Park in Brooklyn and converted the empty barn into a public pavilion restaurant. Opening on October 20, 1934, Tavern on the Green debuted as a modestly priced retreat where everyday New Yorkers could buy a sit-down meal for a dollar or dance to live brass bands on an outdoor terrace.
Moses retained the exterior Victorian brickwork while stripping out livestock stalls in favor of wood-paneled dining rooms and sweeping window bays. The move anchored an enduring precedent: the property belonged to the public park system, but its commercial operations relied on private concessionaires overseen by city regulators.