Separating Myth from Reality: Who Was Chief Cochise and What Did He Fight for?

Find a thorough breakdown on Separating Myth from Reality: Who Was Chief Cochise and What Did He Fight for.

The uneasy peace shattered in February 1861 due to the reckless actions of a single, inexperienced officer. In January of that year, an unidentified raiding party struck the ranch of settler John Ward, stealing cattle and kidnapping a 12-year-old boy named Felix Ward. Ward immediately blamed Cochise's band, despite having zero physical evidence.

Second Lieutenant George Nicholas Bascom, fresh out of West Point, led an infantry detachment to Apache Pass to recover the child. Bascom invited Cochise to his camp under a white flag of truce. Cochise arrived with his brother, two nephews, his wife, and two children, expecting a routine diplomatic exchange. Instead, Bascom accused him of the abduction and declared the entire family under arrest until the boy was returned.

Cochise, realizing the trap, pulled a knife from his belt, slashed open the canvas wall of the army tent, and broke through a line of sentries despite taking multiple bullet wounds. Bascom held the remaining family members as hostages. Over the following days, Cochise captured several American civilians and attempted an exchange. Bascom refused to trade unless the kidnapped child was produced, a demand Cochise could not fulfill because another Apache group, the Coyotero band, had taken the boy. Bascom hanged Cochise's brother and nephews from the branches of an oak tree near the pass.

In response, Cochise executed his captives. The diplomatic bridge between the Chiricahua Apache and the United States military was incinerated. For the next eleven years, southeastern Arizona descended into an unrelenting war of ambush and counter-offensive.