Inside Athenian Room: Why Tina Fey's Favorite Chicago Spot Still Draws Massive Crowds
In October 2010, Tina Fey appeared on late-night television and uttered a sentence that altered the kitchen's daily prep volume indefinitely: she proclaimed that the roasted chicken at Athenian Room was the single best meal in Chicago. At the time, Fey was riding high on the success of 30 Rock and her Sarah Palin parodies. When she spoke about food, audiences listened.
The reaction was immediate. Within 48 hours of the broadcast, local news outlets like CBS News and the Chicago Tribune converged on Webster Avenue to document lines stretching down the block. Dino Sohos, whose family opened the tavern in 1972, found himself ordering poultry by the crate load just to avoid selling out before dinner rush. For staff accustomed to steady neighborhood traffic, the sudden crush of out-of-town visitors created a frenzied baptism by fire.
Fey had discovered the restaurant during the 1990s while training at The Second City in Old Town. Broke, overworked, and hungry, young performers routinely drifted north to Lincoln Park for dense, affordable protein. Decades later, the endorsement was not a paid promotional stunt. It was genuine nostalgia for an authentic Greek restaurant that never cut corners to inflate its margins.